Build your new home in Lake Butler FL with Toll Brothers. Choose from a great selection of new construction home designs with flexible floor plans.

New Homes in Lake Butler FL - New Construction Homes | Toll Brothers® 

30-Year Fixed Rate with 2/1 Buydown Program
Limited Time Only on Select Homes

[{"rate":3.625,"apr":5.68},{"rate":4.625,"apr":5.68},{"rate":5.625,"apr":5.68}]

For a limited time on select quick move-in homes, Toll Brothers Mortgage Company is offering reduced interest rates for the first two years of your 30-year fixed loan and then a locked interest rate starting with year three for the remaining loan term. This offer is only available on homes that close by October 31, 2025, so take advantage of this great rate now.

Discover the Toll Brothers 2/1 Buydown Program and give yourself one more reason to make your next move. 

Imbued with the region’s traditional, historic Florida ambiance, Bartram Ranch includes a variety of home designs featuring large yards and open space between the homes. The community offers easy accessibility to a myriad of shopping and dining options, Atlantic Ocean beaches, and downtown Jacksonville via 9B and I-95. Additionally, top-rated St. Johns County schools are within minutes of the community.

Bartram Ranch is a picturesque neighborhood featuring all-new architecture on oversized home sites built with Toll Brothers' commitment to quality, value, and craftsmanship. Imbued with the region’s

Julington Traditional

Samuel Farmhouse

Barnwell Farmhouse

Barnwell Elite Craftsman

Julington

Delmonico

Westbrook

Abigail

Mayport

Samuel

Barnwell

Barnwell Elite

Capstone

Coming Soon Home Site

Bartram Ranch

DYOH V2

Build the home of your dreams on this one of a kind preserve home site.  Imagine the privacy afforded by the preserve views to the side and rear of this location.  Offering the opportunity to choose your home design, architectural features and design finishes in this serene, gated community.

Learn More About
Financing Offers
Available Now

Free Upgraded Garage Floor Finish on Select Homes

Show Coming Soon Banner

Build the home of your dreams on this one of a kind preserve home site.  Imagine the privacy afforded by the preserve views to the side and rear of this location.  Offering the opportunity to choose

Bartram Ranch is a picturesque neighborhood featuring all-new architecture on oversized home sites built with Toll Brothers' commitment to quality, value, and craftsmanship.

Within the Shores at RiverTown master planned community in St. Johns, Florida, the Atlantic Collection offers modern single-family homes and the exquisite lifestyle we dream of. This beautiful riverfront new home community boasts an onsite nature preserve and features luxury living, an impressive lifestyle, top-rated schools, and a serene backdrop, all in one setting. With resort-style amenities and ample opportunity for outdoor recreation, including a waterside boardwalk, life in Shores at RiverTown is sure to be both luxurious and exciting.

The Atlantic Collection offers luxury single-family homes within the prestigious and master-planned Shores at Rivertown new home community in St. Johns, Florida. Within the Shores at RiverTown master

Mayflower Carolina

Mayflower Craftsman

Carnation Craftsman

Mayflower

Tideland

Water Lily

Carnation

Osprey

Shores at RiverTown - Atlantic Collection

The Atlantic Collection offers luxury single-family homes within the prestigious and master-planned Shores at Rivertown new home community in St. Johns, Florida.

Within the Shores at RiverTown master planned community in St. Johns, Florida, the Gulf Collection offers modern single-family homes and a lifestyle you won't want to miss out on. This beautiful riverfront new home community boasts an onsite nature preserve and features luxury living, an impressive lifestyle, top-rated schools, and a serene backdrop, all in one setting. With resort-style amenities and ample opportunity for outdoor recreation, including a waterside boardwalk, life at Shores at RiverTown is sure to be both luxurious and exciting.

The Gulf Collection offers luxury single-family homes within the prestigious and master-planned Shores at Rivertown new home community in St. Johns, Florida. Within the Shores at RiverTown master

Petunia Coastal

Sparrow Elite Carolina

Edgeport Carolina

Edgeport Craftsman

Caspian Carolina

Caspian Craftsman

Sparrow

Petunia

Sparrow Elite

Edgeport

Caspian

Kepler

Shores at RiverTown - Gulf Collection

The Gulf Collection offers luxury single-family homes within the prestigious and master-planned Shores at Rivertown new home community in St. Johns, Florida.

An exciting destination within the Shores at RiverTown sets the stage for gracious living by America's Luxury Home Builder.  The Riverview collection features low-maintenance townhome living with elegant open floor plan designs, elevated finishes, and high-end included features.  The architecture will welcome you home to spacious entertaining areas, loft spaces full of opportunity and stunning views of Florida's lovely St. Johns River providing water access and unbelievable sunset views.  

Toll Brothers offers personalization options at our award-winning North Florida Design Studio - choose designer lighting, hardwood flooring, cabinets and countertops, security and home automation, and much more!

The Riverview Collection, part of the Rivertown master plan, is a new home community in St. Johns, FL offering luxury townhomes with stunning views, elevated finishes and modern designs

Macaw Carolina

Macaw Coastal

Ibis Coastal

Lark Coastal

Lark Carolina

Macaw

Ibis

Lark

Shores at RiverTown - Riverview Collection

The Riverview Collection, part of the Rivertown master plan, is a new home community in St. Johns, FL offering luxury townhomes with stunning views, elevated finishes and modern designs.

Shores at RiverTown is a new home community offering luxury single-family homes and waterfront townhomes with access to exciting resort-style amenities and opportunities for private docks in desirable St. Johns County.

Shores at RiverTown

Located in St. Johns, Mill Creek Forest features spacious one- and two-story single-family home designs, ranging from 2,670 to over 3,440 square feet with available 3-car garages, featuring Craftsman, Coastal and Farmhouse exteriors. Several home sites will offer expansive preserve views.

The Magnolia Collection features one- and two-story single-family home designs with available 3-car garages from approximately 2,670 to 3,440 square feet. Located in St. Johns, Mill Creek Forest

Alice Farmhouse

Ruth Elite Farmhouse

Ruth Elite Craftsman

Alice

Robin

Egan

Hannah

Ruth

Ruth Elite

Mill Creek Forest - Magnolia

The Magnolia Collection features one- and two-story single-family home designs with available 3-car garages from approximately 2,670 to 3,440 square feet.

Located in St. Johns, Mill Creek Forest showcases spacious one- and two-story single-family home designs, ranging from 1,918 to 2,491 square feet, featuring Craftsman, Coastal and Farmhouse exteriors. Several home sites will offer expansive preserve views.

Experience the best of Florida’s lifestyle with resort-style amenities including a sparkling swimming pool, a state-of-the-art fitness center, and a tot lot.

Mill Creek Forest will provide the natural beauty of Northeast Florida conveniently located close to shopping, dining, the beaches, and downtown Jacksonville.

Located in St. Johns, Mill Creek Forest showcases spacious one- and two-story single-family home designs, ranging from 1,918 to 2,491 square feet, featuring Craftsman, Coastal and Farmhouse exteriors

Penelope

Ella

Liam

June

Well-designed kitchens with extra counter space for entertaining

Mill Creek Forest - Meadows

Located in St. Johns, Mill Creek Forest showcases spacious one- and two-story single-family home designs, ranging from 1,918 to 2,491 square feet, featuring Craftsman, Coastal and Farmhouse exteriors.

Mill Creek Forest is a gated, new home community in prestigious St. Johns, FL, that features modern one- and two-story homes on private, wooded home sites with access to resort-style amenities and beautiful lakeside views.

Mill Creek Forest

Discover an ideal blend of luxury and excitement at Toll Brothers at RiversEdge, a beautiful new community of luxury townhomes in Jacksonville, FL, on the banks of the St. Johns River. Boasting 2-car garages and rooftop terraces included in every home design, these spacious 3-story floor plans offer unrivaled options for personalization as well as gorgeous wooded and riverfront views. Toll Brothers at RiversEdge is within walking distance to the Southbank Riverwalk Extension, providing residents with convenient access to scenic walking paths, trending restaurants, and shopping districts, as well as amazing outdoor recreation. Experience your dream lifestyle at Toll Brothers at RiversEdge.

Toll Brothers at RiversEdge is a new community of luxury townhomes in Jacksonville, FL, offering spacious home designs with riverfront views, rooftop terraces, 2-car garages, and access to the exciting Southbank Riverwalk Extension

Atlantic Modern

Elder Contemporary

Elder Modern

Atlantic

Elder

Toll Brothers at RiversEdge

Toll Brothers at RiversEdge is a new community of luxury townhomes in Jacksonville, FL, offering spacious home designs with riverfront views, rooftop terraces, 2-car garages, and access to the exciting Southbank Riverwalk Extension.

A sanctuary of elegance and comfort, Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Cypress Collection features new single-family homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL. These luxurious home designs range from 1,700 to 2,300+ square feet and offer a sophisticated array of personalization options at the Toll Brothers Design Studio. This community boasts premier access to an array of incredible master plan amenities, including a clubhouse, sparkling swimming pool, fitness center, and beautifully landscaped parks, providing an unparalleled lifestyle of comfort and convenience. Situated within the esteemed St. Johns County School District and close to St. Augustine’s beaches, Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Cypress Collection perfectly blends luxury, comfort, and top-tier education in one idyllic location.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Cypress Collection offers an elegant selection of single-family homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL, with premier access to incredible amenities and a location within the esteemed St. Johns County School District

Cobblestone Modern Coastal

Flagler Transitional

Halcyn Modern Coastal

Halcyn Modern Farmhouse

Sailor Modern Farmhouse

Sailor Modern Coastal

Cobblestone

Halcyn

Sailor

Newbrook - Cypress Collection

Show Mortgage Calculator

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Cypress Collection offers an elegant selection of single-family homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL, with premier access to incredible amenities and a location within the esteemed St. Johns County School District.

Situated in a prime location just minutes from historic downtown St. Augustine with its vibrant shopping and dining and the pristine Atlantic beaches, Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Dogwood Collection is a beautiful community offering new homes in St. Augustine, FL. Thoughtfully designed floor plans ranging from 2,100-2,500+ square feet with 3 to 4 bedrooms and 2 to 3 bathrooms create the opportunity for you to find the home design that is perfect for you. Plus, you’ll personalize all the spaces of your home that matter most at the Toll Brothers Design Studio with sophisticated fixtures and finishes.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Dogwood Collection offers new homes in St. Augustine, FL, conveniently located near the shopping and dining of historic downtown and to top-rated St. Johns County schools

Oceana Transitional

Pompano Transitional

Seabelle Transitional

Seamark Transitional

Seamark Modern Farmhouse

Oceana

Pompano

Seabelle

Seamark

Newbrook - Dogwood Collection

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Dogwood Collection offers new homes in St. Augustine, FL, conveniently located near the shopping and dining of historic downtown and to top-rated St. Johns County schools.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Juniper Collection is the epitome of comfort and sophistication. This community of new construction homes in St. Augustine, FL, offers elegance in a prime location. Close to exciting shopping and dining in downtown St. Augustine, this collection is a harmonious blend of luxury, convenience, and community. With expansive home designs ranging from 2,600 to 3,200+ square feet and the opportunity to personalize fixtures and finishes at the Toll Brothers Design Studio, your dream home awaits. Plus, proximity to top-rated St. Johns County's top-rated schools truly make this the ideal place to call home.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Juniper Collection offers new construction homes in St. Augustine, FL, featuring spacious home designs ranging from 2,600-3,200+ sq. ft. ideally situated near premier shopping, dining, and gorgeous beaches

Scarlett Modern Coastal

Scarlett Modern Farmhouse

Barnwell Elite Transitional

Bellflower Modern Coastal

Scarlett

Bellflower

Cordata

Newbrook - Juniper Collection

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Juniper Collection offers new construction homes in St. Augustine, FL, featuring spacious home designs ranging from 2,600-3,200+ sq. ft. ideally situated near premier shopping, dining, and gorgeous beaches.

A community of beautiful new homes in St. Augustine, FL, Newbrook at SilverLeaf - River Birch Collection offers expansive home designs ranging from 2,800-3,400+ square feet with 4 to 5 bedrooms and 3 to 4 bathrooms. Situated just minutes from gorgeous Atlantic Beaches and historic downtown St. Augustine, this master-planned community truly offers the best of all worlds. Resort-style amenities exclusive to Newbrook residents, like a clubhouse and pool, in addition to the amenities at SilverLeaf allow you to enjoy the Florida lifestyle.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - River Birch Collection features expansive new homes in St. Augustine, FL, with high-end finishes and access to resort-style amenities as well as the highly coveted St. Johns School District

Mayport Modern Farmhouse

Samuel Transitional

Samuel Modern Farmhouse

Belfort Transitional

Belfort

Newbrook - River Birch Collection

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - River Birch Collection features expansive new homes in St. Augustine, FL, with high-end finishes and access to resort-style amenities as well as the highly coveted St. Johns School District.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Spruce Collection is a new community offering luxury homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL, that range from 3,700 to 4,700+ square feet with 4 to 5 bedrooms. As part of the desirable SilverLeaf masterplan, Newbrook provides access to not only the master plan amenities, like a resort-style clubhouse, pool, and fitness center, but also exclusive amenities just for Newbrook residents. With its proximity to beautiful beaches, vibrant downtown St. Augustine, and exemplary St. Johns County schools, this community is the perfect blend of luxury, sophistication, and relaxation.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Spruce Collection features an exquisite selection of luxury homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL, ranging from 3,700 to 4,700+ sq. ft. with expansive floor plans and access to outstanding amenities

Delmonico Modern Farmhouse

Delmonico Transitional

Arcadia Modern Coastal

Beckingham Modern Coastal

Arcadia

Beckingham

Devonhurst

Newbrook - Spruce Collection

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Spruce Collection features an exquisite selection of luxury homes for sale in St. Augustine, FL, ranging from 3,700 to 4,700+ sq. ft. with expansive floor plans and access to outstanding amenities.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Towns Collection offers new construction townhomes in St. Augustine, FL, that perfectly combine luxury and comfort. These expansive new townhomes, ranging from 1,800-2,100+ square feet and offering 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, have been designed with you in mind. Nestled in a picturesque setting, the community is just a stone's throw away from the pristine beaches of St. Augustine, creating an everyday paradise with a low-maintenance lifestyle that gives you the time to enjoy it. Plus, Newbrook at SilverLeaf is surrounded by a plethora of shopping destinations and gourmet dining options for you to enjoy.

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Towns Collection offers new construction townhomes in St. Augustine, FL, featuring a desirable low-maintenance lifestyle with access to beautiful beaches and exquisite shopping and dining

Castillo Modern Farmhouse

Lightner Modern Farmhouse

Settler Modern Farmhouse

Fairfield Modern Farmhouse

Newbrook - Towns Collection

Newbrook at SilverLeaf - Towns Collection offers new construction townhomes in St. Augustine, FL, featuring a desirable low-maintenance lifestyle with access to beautiful beaches and exquisite shopping and dining.

Part of the exciting SilverLeaf master plan, Newbrook is a gated community of new luxury homes in St. Augustine, FL, offering access to an amazing collection of amenities exclusive to Newbrook residents and a pristine location close to Florida beaches.

Appreciate gorgeous Florida sunsets poolside

Newbrook

Nestled amid farmland and lush open space, Iron Branch is a gated community in St. Augustine, FL, featuring gorgeous homes set on expansive 1.5-acre home sites. Choose from a selection of modern one- and two-story home designs with over 3,700 square feet, bright open living areas, gourmet kitchens, spectacular covered lanais, and options including multigenerational suites. With the assistance of a talented Design Studio Consultant, you have the opportunity to outfit every space with high-end fixtures and finishes at the Toll Brothers Design Studio. Spend time relaxing by the 14-acre lake with a dock or gather with neighbors at the pavilion. Located within the acclaimed St. Johns County School District, this private haven is just 10 minutes from I-95 and close to a variety of shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

Surrounded by lush natural landscapes, Iron Branch is a gated community in St. Augustine, FL, offering 1.5-acre home sites ideal for outdoor enjoyment, expansive home designs with optional multi-gen suites, and exceptional personalization options

Flint

Andrea

Iron Branch

Turn HBQ on for Future Community

Surrounded by lush natural landscapes, Iron Branch is a gated community in St. Augustine, FL, offering 1.5-acre home sites ideal for outdoor enjoyment, expansive home designs with optional multi-gen suites, and exceptional personalization options.

Our quick move-in homes offer a professionally selected floor plan, designer-curated finishes, and some of our most-enviable upgrades, all included. These exclusive homes save you an exceptional amount of time on a new home and allow you to enjoy all the luxury Toll Brothers finishes and features that make it a dream home quicker than ever.

Set in the master-planned community of eTown, Newton residents enjoy access to Recharge, eTown’s amenity center which includes a resort-style pool with zero entry and an adjoining three-lane lap pool, a high-tech fitness center,  outdoor yoga lawn, rooftop patio, kids playground, event lawn, gathering spaces, and dog park.  In the heart of eTown will be the future Village Center with shops, restaurants, and gathering spaces.

Newton is located in the highly desirable area of Jacksonville, off I-295 and Florida 9B, and is just minutes to nearby schools, medical, and any convenience you may need.

Newton is a gated, townhome community featuring the perfect balance of luxury home designs and low-maintenance living in the heart of eTown. Our quick move-in homes offer a professionally selected

Lark Modern Farmhouse

Newton

Newton is a gated, townhome community featuring the perfect balance of luxury home designs and low-maintenance living in the heart of eTown.

Mariposa at EverRange is a new home community in Jacksonville, FL, situated in a highly anticipated master plan. These beautiful single- and two-story homes range from 2,105 to 2,899 square feet and offer 3 to 4 bedrooms, 2 to 3 bathrooms, plus options for flex rooms, lofts, and first-floor primary bedrooms. At the Toll Brothers Design Studio, you can choose high-end fixtures and finishes to create spaces that perfectly reflect your style. Relax on your peaceful covered lanai or enjoy the fantastic community amenities, where you can swim, play, work out, and socialize. Located close to a variety of shopping, dining, and beaches, this golf cart-friendly community will also benefit from future connection to eTown and Nocatee.

Mariposa at EverRange is a new home community in Jacksonville, FL, featuring beautiful single-family homes, most with scenic preserve and water views, all nestled in a vibrant, golf cart-friendly master plan with incredible amenities

Mariposa at EverRange

Mariposa at EverRange is a new home community in Jacksonville, FL, featuring beautiful single-family homes, most with scenic preserve and water views, all nestled in a vibrant, golf cart-friendly master plan with incredible amenities.

Find your new home in the Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection and indulge in a lifestyle of relaxation and recreation. Residents of this luxury low-maintenance 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL, will enjoy an array of private Regency amenities, including a clubhouse, a sparkling resort-style pool, fitness center, pickleball courts, a yoga lawn, and putting green. Just a short stroll or golf cart ride away, additional master-plan amenities await, from a playground and splash park to an event lawn, table tennis, and an additional clubhouse and pool. Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection features exceptional single-level living with a selection of single-family home designs ranging from 1,980–2,251 sq. ft. with 2–3 bedrooms, 2–2.5 bathrooms, and 2-car garages. Personalize your new home’s fixtures and finishes with the help of a professional designer at the Toll Brothers Design Studio and create a space that reflects your unique taste and style in this vibrant destination for active adults.

Nestled with a 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL, featuring private resident amenities and access to master-plan amenities, Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection offers single-story homes up to 2,251 sq. ft. with 2–3 bedrooms and 2–2.5 bathrooms

Adonis

Blossom

Carling

Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection

Nestled with a 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL, featuring private resident amenities and access to master-plan amenities, Regency at EverRange - Acadia Collection offers single-story homes up to 2,251 sq. ft. with 2–3 bedrooms and 2–2.5 bathrooms.

Enjoy resort-style living at its finest when you create your dream home in the Regency at EverRange - Willow Collection. Tucked within an exceptional low-maintenance 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL, the Willow Collection features elegant new single-story homes with modern, open floor plans perfect for hosting family and friends. Home designs range up to 2,896 sq. ft. with 3–4 bedrooms, 2.5–3 bathrooms, 3-car garages, and beautiful exteriors. Choose from a wide array of personalization options at the Toll Brothers Design Studio to bring your unique vision of home to life in this incredible destination for active adults, which features both private Regency amenities and access to engaging master-plan amenities. Future community amenities include a clubhouse, a sparkling resort-style pool, fitness center, pickleball courts, a yoga lawn, putting green, and more. Just a short stroll or golf cart ride away, additional master-plan amenities await, from a playground and splash park to an event lawn, table tennis, and an additional clubhouse and pool.

Offering single-story homes ranging from 2,550 to 2,896 sq. ft. with 3–4 bedrooms, 2.5–3 bathrooms, and 3-car garages, Regency at EverRange - Willow Collection features resort-style living in an amenity-rich 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL

Avina

Caroline

Regency at EverRange - Willow Collection

Offering single-story homes ranging from 2,550 to 2,896 sq. ft. with 3–4 bedrooms, 2.5–3 bathrooms, and 3-car garages, Regency at EverRange - Willow Collection features resort-style living in an amenity-rich 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL.

Regency at EverRange is a gated 55+ community in Jacksonville, FL, offering low-maintenance living, access to master-plan and private resort-style amenities, and two collections of new luxury single-story homes.

Regency at EverRange

Recently Viewed

New Homes for Sale near Lake Butler

Bartram Ranch

Shores at RiverTown

Talk to an Expert

Mill Creek Forest

Toll Brothers at RiversEdge

Newbrook

Iron Branch

Newton

Mariposa at EverRange

Regency at EverRange

Reflections at Seabrook

Seabrook Village